| Title | Fun | Rarity | Loose | CIB | New | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Super Mario Galaxy Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 98 | R1 | $11 | $16 | $67 | |
| Super Mario Galaxy [Nintendo Selects] Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 98 | $9 | $15 | $32 | ||
| Super Mario Odyssey Switch · Nintendo · Platformer | 98 | R1 | $25 | $30 | $40 | |
| Super Mario Odyssey [Not For Resale] Switch · Nintendo | 98 | — | $32 | — | ||
| Super Mario Odyssey [Starter Pack] Switch · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 98 | — | $41 | $135 | ||
| Super Mario Galaxy 2 Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 97 | R2 | $17 | $22 | $49 | |
| Super Mario Galaxy 2 [Nintendo Selects] Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 97 | — | $21 | $40 | ||
| Super Mario 64 N64 · Nintendo · Platformer | 96 | R1 | $36 | $130 | $1.9k | |
| Super Mario 64 [Not for Resale] N64 · Nintendo · Platformer | 96 | $190 | — | — | ||
| Super Mario 64 [Player's Choice] N64 · Nintendo · Platformer | 96 | $37 | $127 | $1.0k | ||
| Super Mario Bros. 3 NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 96 | R1 | $16 | $75 | $1.1k | |
| Super Mario Bros. 3 [Challenge Set] NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 96 | $61 | $126 | $619 | ||
| Super Mario Bros. 3 [Left Bros] NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 96 | $21 | $186 | — | ||
| Super Mario Galaxy + Super Mario Galaxy 2 Switch · Nintendo | 96 | R3 | $37 | $44 | $50 | |
| Super Mario All-Stars + Super Mario World SNES · Nintendo · Platformer | 95 | R3 | $38 | — | — | |
| Super Mario World SNES · Nintendo · Platformer | 95 | R1 | $16 | $481 | $2.5k | |
| Super Mario World [Player's Choice] SNES · Nintendo · Platformer | 95 | $18 | $363 | — | ||
| Super Mario Bros. NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 94 | R2 | $13 | $254 | — | |
| Super Mario Bros. [5 Screw] NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 94 | $19 | $290 | — | ||
| Super Mario Bros. [Matte Sticker] NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 94 | $217 | $11k | — | ||
| Super Mario Bros. [Gloss Sticker] NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 94 | — | $1.7k | — | ||
| Super Mario Bros. - Duck Hunt - World Class Track Meet NES · Nintendo | 94 | R2 | $7 | — | — | |
| Super Mario Bros. - Duck Hunt NES · Nintendo | 94 | R1 | $8 | — | — | |
| Super Mario 3D World Wii U · Nintendo · Platformer | 93 | R1 | $6 | $11 | $23 | |
| Super Mario 3D World [Family Game Of The Year] Wii U · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 93 | — | $15 | — | ||
| Super Mario 3D World [Nintendo Selects] Wii U · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 93 | $7 | $9 | $19 | ||
| Super Mario 3D World [Not For Resale] Wii U · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 93 | — | $11 | $25 | ||
| Super Mario Bros. Deluxe GB Color · Nintendo · Platformer | 93 | R1 | $25 | $67 | $375 | |
| Super Mario Bros. Wonder Switch · Nintendo · Platformer | 93 | R1 | $28 | $34 | $40 | |
| Super Mario Kart SNES · Nintendo · Racing | 93 | R2 | $28 | $105 | $760 | |
| Super Mario Kart [Player's Choice] SNES · Nintendo · Racing | 93 | $29 | $76 | $475 | ||
| Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | R1 | $17 | $71 | $195 | |
| Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3 [Not for Resale] GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | $36 | — | — | ||
| Super Mario Sunshine Gamecube · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | R1 | $29 | $46 | $598 | |
| Super Mario Sunshine [Kmart] Gamecube · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | — | $59 | — | ||
| Super Mario Sunshine [Not for Resale] Gamecube · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | — | $41 | — | ||
| Super Mario Sunshine [Player's Choice] Gamecube · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | — | $41 | $186 | ||
| Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2 GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | R1 | $19 | $59 | $283 | |
| Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2 [Not for Resale] GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 92 | $17 | — | — | ||
| Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2 [Player's Choice] GB Advance · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 92 | — | $55 | — | ||
| Super Mario All-Stars SNES · Nintendo · Platformer | 91 | R1 | $18 | $84 | $1.4k | |
| Super Mario All-Stars [Player's Choice] SNES · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 91 | $21 | $66 | $521 | ||
| Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island SNES · Nintendo · Platformer | 91 | R2 | $38 | $138 | — | |
| Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island [Not for Resale] SNES · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 91 | $154 | — | — | ||
| Super Mario 3D Land 3DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | R1 | $9 | $14 | $25 | |
| Super Mario 3D Land [Nintendo Selects] 3DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | $10 | $14 | $25 | ||
| Super Mario 3D Land [Not for Resale] 3DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | — | — | — | ||
| Super Mario 3D Land [White Case] 3DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | — | $15 | $49 | ||
| Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury Switch · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 90 | R2 | $28 | $34 | $40 | |
| Super Mario Maker Wii U · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | R1 | $7 | $11 | $27 | |
| Super Mario Maker [Book Bundle] Wii U · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | — | $13 | $39 | ||
| Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars SNES · Nintendo · RPG | 90 | R2 | $59 | $243 | — | |
| Super Mario Bros. 2 NES · Nintendo · Platformer | 88 | R1 | $19 | $77 | $5.5k | |
| Super Mario Maker 2 Switch · Nintendo · Platformer | 88 | R2 | $22 | $26 | $41 | |
| Super Mario Maker 2 [Online Bundle] Switch · Nintendo · Platformer | 88 | — | — | — | ||
| Super Mario 64 DS DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 87 | R1 | $14 | $25 | $51 | |
| Super Mario 64 DS [Not for Resale] DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 87 | — | — | — | ||
| Super Mario RPG Switch · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 87 | R3 | $17 | $21 | $27 | |
| Super Mario 3D All-Stars Switch · Nintendo | 83 | R1 | $61 | $70 | $102 | |
| Super Mario Party Jamboree Switch · Nintendo · Party | 83 | R2 | $37 | $39 | $47 | |
| Super Mario Party Jamboree [Online Bundle] Switch · Nintendo · Party | 83 | — | — | — | ||
| Super Mario Advance GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 82 | R1 | $14 | $53 | $203 | |
| Super Mario Advance [Not for Resale] GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 82 | $55 | — | — | ||
| Super Mario Advance [Player's Choice] GB Advance · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 82 | — | $46 | $141 | ||
| Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins Game Boy · Nintendo · Platformer | 82 | R1 | $20 | $84 | $650 | |
| Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins [Player's Choice] Game Boy · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 82 | $19 | $93 | $380 | ||
| Super Mario Bros. [Classic NES Series] GB Advance · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 81 | R4 | $26 | $66 | $382 | |
| Super Mario Land Game Boy · Nintendo · Platformer | 81 | R1 | $17 | $94 | $2.1k | |
| Super Mario Land [Player's Choice] Game Boy · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 81 | $17 | $66 | $456 | ||
| Super Mario All-Stars Limited Edition Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 76 | R2 | $17 | $25 | $51 | |
| Super Mario All-Stars Limited Edition [Nintendo Selects] Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 76 | $14 | $20 | $42 | ||
| Super Mario Strikers Gamecube · Nintendo · Sports | 76 | R2 | $39 | $61 | $294 | |
| Super Mario Strikers [Best Seller] Gamecube · Nintendo · Sports | 76 | — | $55 | — | ||
| Super Mario Strikers [Not for Resale] Gamecube · Nintendo · Sports | 76 | — | — | — | ||
| Super Mario Maker 3DS · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 75 | R2 | $6 | $13 | $18 | |
| Super Mario Maker [Nintendo Selects] 3DS · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 75 | $6 | $11 | $16 | ||
| Super Mario Party Switch · Nintendo · Party | 74 | R1 | $19 | $24 | $40 | |
| Super Mario Party [Controller Bundle] Switch · Nintendo · Party | 74 | — | — | — | ||
| Super Mario Advance 4: Series 2 [e-Reader] GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 42 | — | — | — | ||
| Super Mario Advance 4: Series 1 [e-Reader] GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 41 | — | $74 | — | ||
| Mario Kart: Super Circuit GB Advance · Nintendo · Racing | 91 | R1 | $16 | $51 | $201 | |
| Mario Kart: Super Circuit [Not for Resale] GB Advance · Nintendo · Racing | 91 | $29 | — | — | ||
| Mario Kart: Super Circuit [Player's Choice] GB Advance · Nintendo · Racing | 91 | — | $48 | $150 | ||
| Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga GB Advance · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 90 | R2 | $23 | $86 | $238 | |
| Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga [Not for Resale] GB Advance · Nintendo · RPG | 90 | $42 | — | — | ||
| Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga [Player's Choice] GB Advance · Nintendo · RPG | 90 | — | $76 | $199 | ||
| New Super Mario Bros. DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | R1 | $14 | $21 | $65 | |
| New Super Mario Bros. [Not for Resale] DS · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | $15 | — | — | ||
| Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3 GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | R2 | $15 | $71 | $191 | |
| Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3 [Not for Resale] GB Advance · Nintendo · Platformer | 90 | $21 | — | — | ||
| Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3 [Player's Choice] GB Advance · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 90 | — | $76 | — | ||
| Super Paper Mario Wii · Nintendo · RPG | 85 | R2 | $10 | $16 | $65 | |
| Super Paper Mario [Nintendo Selects] Wii · Nintendo · RPG | 85 | $7 | $14 | $37 | ||
| Wario Land: Super Mario Land 3 Game Boy · Nintendo · Platformer | 84 | R2 | $23 | $116 | — | |
| Wario Land: Super Mario Land 3 [Player's Choice] Game Boy · Nintendo · Action & Adventure | 84 | $25 | $103 | — | ||
| New Super Mario Bros. Wii Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 83 | R1 | $18 | $23 | $50 | |
| New Super Mario Bros. Wii [Not For Resale] Wii · Nintendo · Platformer | 83 | — | — | $37 | ||
| Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga - Bowser's Minions 3DS · Nintendo · RPG | 82 | R4 | $27 | $36 | $43 | |
| Tetris & Dr. Mario SNES · Nintendo · Puzzle | 82 | R3 | $22 | $63 | $168 | |
| Tetris & Dr. Mario [Player's Choice] SNES · Nintendo · Puzzle | 82 | $22 | $54 | — |