| Title | Fun | Rarity | Loose | CIB | New | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sonic the Hedgehog 3 Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 97 | R2 | $27 | $54 | $275 | |
| Sonic the Hedgehog 3 [Mega Hit Series] Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 97 | $26 | $56 | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog 2 Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 96 | R1 | $8 | $17 | $389 | |
| Sonic the Hedgehog 2 [Cardboard Box] Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 96 | — | — | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog 2 [Not for Resale] Genesis · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 96 | $8 | $15 | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog Master System · SEGA · Platformer | 91 | R6 | $113 | — | — | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed PS Vita · Racing | 90 | R3 | $19 | $20 | $50 | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed [Bonus Edition] PS Vita · Racing | 90 | — | $22 | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog Game Gear · SEGA · Platformer | 90 | R2 | $11 | $102 | $637 | |
| Sonic & Knuckles Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 89 | R3 | $28 | $83 | $380 | |
| Sonic & Knuckles [Not for Resale] Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 89 | $29 | — | — | ||
| Sonic CD Sega CD · SEGA · Platformer | 89 | R1 | $43 | $106 | — | |
| Sonic CD [Not for Resale] Sega CD · SEGA · Platformer | 89 | $45 | $69 | — | ||
| Sonic X Shadow Generations [Day One Edition] Switch · Action & Adventure | 89 | — | $16 | $21 | ||
| Sonic X Shadow Generations Switch · Action & Adventure | 89 | R3 | $12 | $16 | $21 | |
| Sonic X Shadow Generations [Collector's Edition] Switch · Action & Adventure | 89 | — | — | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 88 | R1 | $9 | $23 | $213 | |
| Sonic the Hedgehog [Candadian] Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 88 | — | — | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog [ESRB] Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 88 | — | $75 | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog [Not for Resale] Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 88 | $9 | $21 | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog [Sega Classic] Genesis · SEGA · Platformer | 88 | $9 | $17 | — | ||
| Sonic Adventure Dreamcast · SEGA · Platformer | 87 | R1 | $32 | $66 | $184 | |
| Sonic Adventure [Limited Edition] Dreamcast · SEGA · Platformer | 87 | $77 | $749 | — | ||
| Sonic Adventure [Not For Resale] Dreamcast · SEGA · Platformer | 87 | $32 | $83 | — | ||
| Sonic Adventure [Sega All Stars] Dreamcast · SEGA · Platformer | 87 | $34 | $57 | $110 | ||
| Sonic Classics Genesis · SEGA | 87 | R5 | $13 | $35 | $113 | |
| Sonic Mania Switch · Platformer | 87 | R2 | $7 | $10 | $15 | |
| Sonic Mania [Plus] Switch · Action & Adventure | 87 | $14 | $19 | $67 | ||
| Sonic Mania [Collector's Edition] Switch · Action & Adventure | 87 | — | $71 | $108 | ||
| Sonic Mania Plus [Artbook Edition] Switch · Arcade | 87 | — | — | — | ||
| Sonic Mania + Team Sonic Racing Double Pack Switch · Platformer | 85 | R4 | $9 | $13 | $17 | |
| Sonic the Hedgehog 2 Game Gear · SEGA · Platformer | 85 | R1 | $7 | $18 | $32 | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed Xbox 360 · Racing | 84 | R3 | $6 | $10 | $21 | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed [Bonus Edition] Xbox 360 · Racing | 84 | — | $13 | — | ||
| Sonic Adventure 2 Dreamcast · SEGA · Platformer | 84 | R2 | $88 | $180 | $384 | |
| Sonic Rush DS · SEGA · Platformer | 84 | R2 | $17 | $28 | $80 | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed PS3 · SEGA · Racing | 83 | R4 | $4 | $10 | $15 | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed [Bonus Edition] PS3 · SEGA · Racing | 83 | — | $10 | — | ||
| Sonic Chaos Game Gear · SEGA · Platformer | 83 | R2 | $9 | $33 | $79 | |
| Sonic Mega Collection Plus & Super Monkey Ball Deluxe [Platinum Hits] Xbox · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 82 | — | — | — | ||
| Sonic Generations PS3 · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 81 | R3 | $7 | $10 | $15 | |
| Sonic Generations [Greatest Hits] PS3 · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 81 | — | $14 | $16 | ||
| Sonic Rush Adventure DS · SEGA · Platformer | 81 | R3 | $22 | $37 | $95 | |
| Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection PS3 · SEGA | 81 | R2 | $7 | $10 | $16 | |
| Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection [Greatest Hits] PS3 · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 81 | $6 | $9 | $16 | ||
| Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection Xbox 360 | 81 | R2 | $4 | $9 | $18 | |
| Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection [Platinum Hits] Xbox 360 · Action & Adventure | 81 | $4 | $9 | $14 | ||
| Sonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing PS3 · SEGA · Racing | 80 | R3 | $4 | $10 | $16 | |
| Sonic Advance GB Advance · THQ · Action & Adventure | 80 | R3 | $23 | $95 | — | |
| Sonic Advance 2 GB Advance · THQ · Action & Adventure | 80 | R3 | $22 | $96 | — | |
| Sonic Colors Wii · SEGA · Platformer | 80 | R3 | $7 | $13 | $30 | |
| Sonic Generations Xbox 360 · Platformer | 80 | R2 | $6 | $9 | $21 | |
| Sonic Generations [Platinum Hits] Xbox 360 · Platformer | 80 | $3 | $8 | $15 | ||
| Sonic Jam Sega Saturn · SEGA · Platformer | 80 | R5 | $102 | $278 | $552 | |
| Sonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing Wii · SEGA · Racing | 79 | R3 | $9 | $11 | $25 | |
| Sonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing Xbox 360 · Racing | 79 | R3 | $8 | $12 | $21 | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed [Bonus Edition] Wii U · SEGA · Racing | 78 | — | $12 | $28 | ||
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed Wii U · SEGA · Racing | 78 | R3 | $6 | $10 | $29 | |
| Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed [Nintendo Selects] Wii U · SEGA · Racing | 78 | — | $9 | $34 | ||
| Sonic Advance 3 GB Advance · THQ · Platformer | 78 | R3 | $20 | $123 | — | |
| Sonic Colors DS · SEGA · Platformer | 78 | R3 | $12 | $21 | $50 | |
| Sonic Origins Plus Switch · Platformer | 78 | R4 | $11 | $15 | $21 | |
| Sonic Origins Plus [Artbook Edition] Switch · Platformer | 78 | — | $14 | $21 | ||
| Sonic Racing: CrossWorlds Switch | 78 | R4 | $17 | $21 | $32 | |
| Sonic Spinball Game Gear · SEGA · Pinball | 78 | R4 | $12 | $23 | $58 | |
| Sonic & SEGA All-Stars Racing DS · SEGA · Racing | 77 | R3 | $6 | $12 | $49 | |
| Sonic Mega Collection Plus Xbox · SEGA | 77 | R3 | $6 | $13 | $44 | |
| Sonic Mega Collection Plus [Platinum Hits] Xbox · SEGA | 77 | $7 | $12 | $30 | ||
| Sonic Blast Game Gear · SEGA · Platformer | 76 | R5 | $33 | — | — | |
| Sonic Heroes & Super Monkey Ball Deluxe Xbox · SEGA · Platformer | 76 | — | $29 | — | ||
| Sonic Mega Collection Plus PS2 · SEGA | 76 | R2 | $5 | $10 | $29 | |
| Sonic Mega Collection Plus [Greatest Hits] PS2 · SEGA · Platformer | 76 | $4 | $9 | $22 | ||
| Sonic Pinball Party GB Advance · SEGA · Arcade | 76 | R5 | $34 | $137 | $199 | |
| Sonic Rivals 2 - Genesis Collection Pack [Sega Fun Pack] PSP · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 76 | — | — | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog: Triple Trouble Game Gear · SEGA · Platformer | 75 | R3 | $12 | $92 | — | |
| Sonic Drift 2 Game Gear · SEGA · Racing | 74 | R4 | $19 | $94 | — | |
| Sonic Heroes Xbox · SEGA · Platformer | 74 | R4 | $13 | $20 | — | |
| Sonic Heroes [Platinum Hits] Xbox · SEGA · Platformer | 74 | $13 | $19 | — | ||
| Sonic Mega Collection Gamecube · SEGA | 74 | R1 | $9 | $14 | $51 | |
| Sonic Mega Collection [Player's Choice] Gamecube · SEGA | 74 | — | $13 | $48 | ||
| Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood DS · SEGA · RPG | 73 | R4 | $18 | $32 | $73 | |
| Sonic Heroes Gamecube · SEGA · Platformer | 73 | R2 | $21 | $35 | $70 | |
| Sonic Heroes [Player's Choice] Gamecube · SEGA · Platformer | 73 | — | $32 | $84 | ||
| Sonic 3D Blast Sega Saturn · SEGA · Platformer | 72 | R2 | $34 | $75 | $297 | |
| Sonic Adventure 2: Battle Gamecube · SEGA · Platformer | 71 | R2 | $39 | $61 | $204 | |
| Sonic Adventure 2: Battle [Player's Choice] Gamecube · SEGA · Platformer | 71 | — | $62 | $234 | ||
| Sonic Heroes PS2 · SEGA · Platformer | 71 | R3 | $9 | $17 | — | |
| Sonic Heroes [Greatest Hits] PS2 · SEGA · Platformer | 71 | $8 | $13 | $66 | ||
| Sonic Rivals: Double Rivals Attack Pack PSP · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 71 | — | $66 | — | ||
| Sonic Adventure 2: The Trial Dreamcast · SEGA | 70 | R6 | $18 | $44 | — | |
| Sonic Frontiers Switch · Action & Adventure | 70 | R3 | $9 | $12 | $21 | |
| Sonic Generations 3DS · SEGA · Platformer | 70 | R3 | $11 | $18 | $30 | |
| Sonic R Sega Saturn · SEGA · Racing | 70 | R4 | $98 | $213 | $399 | |
| Sonic Unleashed PS2 · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 70 | R4 | $8 | $13 | $37 | |
| Sonic Classic Collection DS · SEGA | 69 | R2 | $9 | $16 | $28 | |
| Sonic Superstars Switch · Platformer | 69 | R3 | $10 | $13 | $22 | |
| Sonic and the Secret Rings Wii · SEGA · Action & Adventure | 68 | R2 | $5 | $9 | $21 | |
| Sonic and the Secret Rings [Target] Wii · SEGA · Platformer | 68 | — | $17 | — | ||
| Sonic the Hedgehog's Gameworld Sega Pico · Party | 68 | R6 | $67 | — | — | |
| Sonic Battle GB Advance · THQ · Fighting | 67 | R4 | $34 | $100 | — |